Historical Returns of a 50/50 Portfolio (or 70/30 or 30/70)

PUBLISHED Nov 29, 2022, 11:09:28 AM        SHARE

img
imgFiPhysician Blog

How to Invest Conservatively for Retirement

If you are retiring soon, you might wonder: how conservatively should I invest? What asset allocation should you have given sequence of return risk?

First, let’s look at a 50/50 portfolio’s historical returns. That’s a good place to start when talking about conservative investing in retirement.

If retiring in the next 5-10 years, you need to mitigate Sequence of Return Risk by de-risking.

Is it time to invest conservatively, given the historical returns of different asset allocations? Let’s start by discussing just what asset allocation means to you.

Define Asset Allocation in Retirement

This is for moderately advanced investors. Please click the links if you need a definition for Sequence of Return Risk or for Asset Allocation.

In brief, if you are drawing down on a portfolio with negative equity returns, there is a good chance of running out of assets in your retirement. While there are many ways to mitigate sequence of returns risk, one tried and true method is to make your asset allocation more conservative.

Historical 50/50 Portfolio Returns

Look at recent history and see how a 50/50 asset allocation performs. If you are going conservative—de-risking—then a 50/50 portfolio is an excellent place to start. We can compare this to 0% and 100% equities and 30/70 and 70/30 portfolios. img (50/50 Asset Allocation recent returns, annualized return, and worst drawdown)

Figure 1 is busy but informative.

Source

Years with Negative Returns since 2000

Note that there are 5 of 18 years when equities had negative returns.

A 100% treasury portfolio avoided all of those negative years but had a year (2013) with negative returns.

Our least aggressive asset allocation (30/70) avoided 2 of the five negative years, but both the 50/50 and the 70/30 suffered from negative returns in all 5 of the years.

Annualized Return

The annualized return (since 1970) for a 50/50 portfolio is 9.1%. This compares to 9.7% for 70/30 historical portfolio returns and 8.5% for a 30/70 portfolio historical returns. Are you surprised that the difference isn’t more significant?

Worst 3-, 6-, and 12-Month Return

You can look at these numbers yourself to compare the different asset allocations. Note how similar the worst 6- and 12-month returns are. On average, it doesn’t get much worse after a terrible six months.

Look now at the bottom of the figure next. Again, the worst drawdown is the percentage decrease from the top of the market to the bottom. But, again, after a dreadful six months, the market does not go down much more after that. Maybe that is a consideration for when to be greedy (when others are fearful) during corrections.

Worst 36- and 60-Month Annualized Returns

Finally, note the worst 3- and 5- year periods.

Since 1970, a 50/50 portfolio had a 3-year return of -6.8% and a 5-year return of -2.1%. Note how these returns compare to the other listed portfolios.

Modern Portfolio and 50/50 Portfolio Historical Returns

The historical numbers above are based on the S&P 500 and treasury bonds. History is nice to understand, lest we repeat it.

Today’s 50/50 asset allocation likely includes the modern portfolio theory. There are many ways to skin a cat and allocate your assets. Let’s look at one version of the modern portfolio and see what a conservative 50/50 portfolio looks like. img (A Modern Portfolio with a conservative 50/50 Asset Allocation)

First, note the annual return of 6.9% and standard deviation of 8.8% in the bottom right corner of figure 1. From our historical results above, this compares to 9.1% and 9.3%, respectively.

Future expected returns are lower for a modern 50/50 portfolio than historical returns. Note, however, that the annual returns are not as disparate when you risk-adjust the returns when you take the standard deviation into account.

Instead of just being S&P 500 and treasure bonds, this version of a modern portfolio includes:

  • 50% Equities (US, International, Emerging, Real Estate)
  • 50% Fixed Income (US bonds, International bonds, Cash)

We can further break down the modern portfolio.

Modern Portfolio for a Conservative Asset Allocation

img (Further breakdown of the conservative asset allocation modern portfolio)

Above, US equities are further broken down into Large Growth and Large Value, with a small addition of Mid Cap and Small Cap.

Bonds in this conservative 50/50 portfolio include 20% Corporate, 10% Government, 4% High Yield, and 1% Municipal. This is not an example of what I would do, but it is one way to skin the asset allocation cat. Some might consider Bond Alternatives.

So, let’s get real. How can you get a 50/50 portfolio in your 401k?

How to Pick a 50/50 Portfolio in a 401k

I get asked: how do you choose the bonds in your 401k? After all, you might be 100% stocks in your brokerage account and Roth, so you need bonds in your 401k. So, look at a popular 401k provider and see how to build a 50/50 portfolio.

What mutual funds are available, and how do you choose which fund to invest in? How can I get to a 50/50 asset allocation in my employer’s 401k?

Why a 50/50 Portfolio?

It may just be that your personalized glidepath has you passing through 50/50 on your way back to a more aggressive portfolio later. Other folks have already won the game and don’t need more risk.

Regardless of the reason, let’s see what a 50/50 asset allocation looks like at a popular online 401k provider

Asset Allocation for a 50/50 Portfolio

img (My 50/50 stocks/fixed income Asset Allocation)

Above, you can see the asset allocation for my 50/50 portfolio at a popular online provider.

On the left, in more detail, my asset allocation is approximately 50% bonds, 30% US equities, and 20% international equities. Again, this mirrors a Boglehead 3 fund portfolio.

The actual funds utilized are broken out into portfolio percentages in the middle. I have about 50% invested in my plan’s only total bond fund option. This is an active bond fund with an average expense ratio. For the remaining 50%, I have 20% international and 10% each in large, mid, and small-cap investments. Regarding global equity, this is overweight US (as US equities are just over 50% of the total). This is overweight (or tilted) towards smaller and mid-sized companies regarding US equity.

Note on the right that this was all deferred compensation as the employer does not offer contributions to this account. They will appear here iHowever if you have employer (or post-tax!) contributions.

How did I get to this asset allocation? First, look at the options available to invest in my 401k plan.

Stock Funds Available in my 401k Plan

img (Stock Funds Available)

You can see there are ten funds to choose from for equity exposure.

As you know, 401k plans are protected by ERISA, so employers limit the investment options to promote their fiduciary responsibility to you. As a result, just bread-and-butter options are available to employees; there are no crazy triple-leveraged ETFs!

So, when picking equities, should I look at the 1, 3, 5, or 10-year returns?

None of the above! Remember, past results don’t imply future returns!

You cannot control the returns of the market. You can only control the fees or expense ratios of what you invest. So, where are the expense ratios?

Expense Ratios

img (Expense Ratios for Stock Funds in my 401k plan)

Above, you can see there are two Large Cap options. There is an inexpensive index fund and a somewhat more expensive value fund. There is a good index fund and an active growth fund for mid-caps.

There is only one small-cap option but five international options! So I picked the inexpensive, broadly diversified international fund and the expensive small-cap fund. I will talk about why I included small caps below.

Fixed Income options in my 401k plan

img (Fixed Income (bond) options in my 401k plan)

Essentially there are only five options for fixed income. Above are two blended funds, two bond investments, and a money market fund.

As I have to pull out money in this account, don’t want target-date funds blended funds for my fixed income option. If all I own is a target-date fund or a blended fund, I have to sell the entire fund–stocks and bonds to get a distribution. So I want the ability to sell either stocks or bonds. This allows me to keep my asset allocation chosen level, depending on which funds I sell. Remember that de-accumulation is very different than accumulation!

Do pay attention to returns on bonds. As opposed to equities, where you cannot know future expected returns, current yields predict future expected returns for fixed income.

Fixed Income in a 50/50 Portfolio

img (Fixed Income and the 50/50 portfolio)

Above are five fixed-income options. The top two are target-date funds for 2020 and current retirees. These have equities in them, so you see their 5-year returns (in red and yellow) are quite a bit more volatile than the good bond funds. This is another reason you don’t want to mix equities and bonds in a distribution portfolio.

My three fixed-income options are: 1) an intermediate core-plus actively managed total bond fund, 2) an inflation-protected bond fund with low yields, and 3) a money market fund.

I might be in a money market fund if I needed all the funds next year. Of course, returns (in green) aren’t sexy, but they “never” lose their value.

Inflation is not a huge concern of mine in the short term, so I chose the higher-yielding bond fund for the next ~ ten years of this plan’s life.

Remember, the funds limit us in the 401k. So if you could choose any bonds fund, you’d want to pick one of these two.

So, that’s how you pick a 50/50 portfolio in a 401k. Let’s step back and summarize now.

Summary: Historical Returns of a 50/50 Portfolio

If you are drawing down on your portfolio in the next 5-10 years, you must pay attention to known Risks. For example, what should your asset allocation be five years from retirement?

Above, we see the historical returns of a 50/50 portfolio and compare them to slightly more or less aggressive asset allocations. Next, see the 70/30 portfolio historical returns and the 30/70 portfolio historical returns. Finally, you can see the worst-case scenarios.

In addition, I also demonstrate a version of a modern portfolio to show how you can portion asset allocation. There are many different ways to allocate your portfolio, and you can be as simple (Bogleheads 3-Fund Portfolio) or as complicated (Merriman’s Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio) as you wish.

Sequence of Return Risk is inevitable when withdrawing from retirement accounts. So plan your pre-retirement glidepath and “go conservative.” You can be in the game for the long haul with a conservative asset allocation.

Originally Posted in FiPhysician


Sound investments
don't happen alone

Find your crew, build teams, compete in VS MODE, and identify investment trends in our evergrowing investment ecosystem. You aren't on an island anymore, and our community is here to help you make informed decisions in a complex world.

More Reads
Warren Buffett Stocks: Louisiana-Pacific Corporation
Image

Louisiana-Pacific Corporation (LPX) is a leader in high-performance building solutions. The company manufactures engineered wood building products for builders, remodelers, and homeowners across the globe.

The Safest Utility Stocks to Invest in Q4 2022
Image

We found the top 5 safest utility stocks based on volatility, drawdown, dividend policy, and dividend cuts. Why are utilities safe? We'll explain why.

7 High Return-of-Capital REITs
Image

Real Estate Investment Trusts (i.e., “REITs”) are tax-advantaged income vehicles that have become increasingly popular with investors and institutions in recent years.

November 2022 Stock Considerations
Image

With a new trading month already in full swing it is time, once again, to highlight some of my potential stock purchases.

Skyworks Solutions (SWKS) Stock: An Undervalued Chipmaker
Image

Over the past five weeks, the market has been up 14.7%. Also, after the CPI report was issued last Thursday morning, the market and almost all the stocks had a tremendous run-up. In two days, the market is up nearly 7%.

2 Recession-Proof Utility Stocks With Safe Dividends
Image

The Fed has raised the Fed Funds rate six times this year to combat inflation and the last four times at a 0.75% clip. The current 4% rate is the highest in well over a decade. But the Central Bank has indicated that it will take more pain to get that inflation genie back in the bottle.

WestRock (WRK) A Dividend Stock Comeback Story
Image

Yes, this is a random WestRock (WRK) dividend stock, come back story. Why is it a comeback? WestRock decimated their dividend during the height of the pandemic from COVID-19. One of the world’s biggest, packaging companies reduced their dividend to $0.20 per share, per quarter from the high of $0.465.

AEP to Focus Capital Investments on Regulated Businesses, Reaffirms Operating Earnings Growth Rate of 6 to 7 Percent
Image

Reaffirmed 2022 operating earnings guidance range of $4.97-$5.07 per share and midpoint of $5.02; 2023 operating earnings guidance range of $5.19 to $5.39 per share; Five-year, $40 billion capital plan emphasizes investment in wires and renewables

Southern Company - A Buy but Not Without Risks
Image

We assess Southern Company to be a buying opportunity. For retail investors, this may be a good time to dollar-cost average into a position in SO.

Dividend Kings in Focus: V. F. Corporation
Image

V.F. Corporation is a giant in the apparel industry. The company’s annual sales amount to nearly $12 billion, but the company has humble beginnings. It started all the way back in 1899 and has seen many twists and turns in the 123 years since.

October 2022 Passive Income Update – Lower Dividends, Higher Passive Income
Image

The market decided to climb back up this month and then interest rates rose once again. The narrative hasn’t changed both Tiff and Powell have said they aren’t done raising interest rates in previous hikes. Unfortunately Tiff played his cards first hoping Powell would follow suit with a .5% raise and the US raised theirs .75% essentially devaluing our dollar. Inflation for Canadians should rise on this move alone as it now costs us more to buy stuff in usd.

Procter & Gamble Stock: Recession Resistant Dividend Aristocrat
Image

When volatility grips the stock market, as it has this past year, income investors should focus on quality dividend growth stocks.

Dividend Income Summary: Lanny’s October 2022 Summary
Image

This is what dividend investing is all about! Investing in dividend stocks allows YOU to earn dividend income, the best passive income stream! Bias, you better believe it.

10 Compelling ESG Stocks That Pay Dividends Now
Image

In the world of investing, the goal is always to compound wealth as efficiently as possible. We think the best way to do that is to buy high-quality dividend stocks, reinvest the dividends, and stay the course over a number of years. However, investors can also infuse their own personal preferences or beliefs into their investing strategy, and still make great returns.

What are the Dividend Policies of the Top Utility Stocks
Image

When an income investor researches utility stocks, the dividend policy is an important decision factor. Here are the dividend policies of the top utility stocks and what they say about the stock.

AMC Stock Forecast, Analysis, Price & News | Is AMC stock a buy
Image

Based on the stock performance over the previous 8 years, AMC has traditionally increased by 80.5% during the following 52 weeks. Learn more!

Is Planet Fitness a Buy or Sell? PLNT target price
Image

Based in Hampton, New Hampshire, Planet Fitness (NYSE:PLNT) is an American fitness facility franchisor and operator. Let's explore it!

Are we in an Index Fund Bubble?
Image

Are we in an index fund bubble? Should you stay the course and keep investing, or should you sell and look for better opportunities? As with most things there is no one size fits all answer. The markets are in a state of turmoil, so it is easy to see why one would think that avoiding certain asset classes might be a good idea. Let’s take a look at index fund investing so you can see if it is right for you.

Dividend Stock Watch List: Lanny’s November 2022 Edition
Image

Welcome back to another dividend stock watch list article! The stock market is still down almost 19% year-to-date, but the last full week of October there definitely was a big push!

Is Verizon a Good Dividend Stock?
Image

Despite the recent uptick, the bear market is still growling in 2022. The Nasdaq and S&P 500 Index are down more than 20% each, while the Dow 30 is doing somewhat better. Consequently, many high-quality stocks’ stock prices have also declined, along with valuations. One such stock is Verizon Communications (VZ), trading near its 52-week low and the lowest price in a decade. But is the stock a value trap, or is Verizon a good dividend stock?

Resources for Publishers
Resources for New Investors
Boosted with BossCoin
Financial Literacy Leaders
user_profile
Tom Hamilton
user_profile
Wise Intelligent
user_profile
Mark Robertson
user_profile
Kevin Matthews II
user_profile
Akeiva Ellis
user_profile
Brendan Dale
user_profile
Kenneth Chavis IV
user_profile
Sharita Humphrey