Concealing Volatility

PUBLISHED Oct 19, 2022, 3:23:45 AM        SHARE


Posted on 5 June 2022 by David Merkel

Photo Credit: Marco Verch Professional Photographer || With some private investments, you can’t tell what the value truly is. Third party professional help occasionally assists dishonesty

Part of my career was based on concealing volatility. I sold Guaranteed Investment Contracts. I helped design and manage several different types of stable value funds. Life insurance contracts get valued at their book value, regardless of what the replacement cost of an equivalent contract would be like presently.

Anytime an investment pool with no current market price has a book value above the underlying value of the investments that it holds, there is risk to those holding the investment pool. The amount of risk can be small yet significant with some types of money market funds. It can be considerably larger in certain types of pooled investments like:

  • Various types of business partnerships, including Private REITs, Real Estate Partnerships, Private Equity, etc.
  • Illiquid debts, such as private credit funds, and notes with limited marketability, whether structured or not.
  • Odd mutual funds that limit withdrawals because they offer “guarantees” of a sort. That applies to Variable Annuities with riders offering guaranteed benefits, if the life insurer becomes insolvent.
  • One-off investment liquid partnerships that are secretive and unusual, like Madoff. The underlying may be illiquid, but the accounting may be fraudulent. Or, the accounting may be fine, but the assets listed are not what is in custody. (With small funds, analyze the auditor, trustees, and custodian.)
  • The value of a company touted by a SPAC promoter may be worth considerably less than what is illustrated.
  • Any investment in public equity or debt pool where the positions are concentrated, and they own a high percentage of the float, or a high amount of the securities relative to the amount that gets traded in an average month. Think of Third Avenue Focused Credit, or Archegos.

I have consistently encouraged readers to “look through” their pooled investments, and consider what the underlying is worth. If you only have a vague idea of what the underlying investments are, look at their public equivalents. A rising tide lifts almost all boats, and a falling tide does the opposite.

There is a conceit within private equity, private credit and private real estate funds that they are less risky; there is no volatility, because we cannot produce an NAV. They have the same volatility as the publicly traded funds, but the volatility is concealed. If trouble hits the public markets 50-75% of the way through the life of a private fund, it will have difficulty selling their investments at levels anywhere near the book value previously claimed by the sponsors.

With consent of the limited partners, perhaps they extend the life of the fund to try to recover value, but that also imposes an opportunity cost on holders who were expecting proceeds from the fund on schedule.

Remember as well that in a scenario like 1929-1932, private funds will be wiped out with similarly leveraged private funds. Aleph Blog has consistently warned about the possibility of depression, plague, war, famine, bad monetary policy and aggressive socialism. We have gotten plague, war, and bad monetary policy. Famine in a sense may come from the Ukraine war and trade restrictions on Russia, at least for the African countries that buy from them.

Thus I encourage readers to avoid private investments that promise no volatility, like the stupid ads for Equity Multiple that run on Bloomberg Radio. All investments involve some type of risk. Just because you can’t or don’t measure the risk doesn’t mean that there is no risk.

Don’t listen to investment sales pitches which tell you to avoid the volatility of the public equity and debt markets, when they are taking the exact same risks in the private market, and they cannot or will not measure the risks for you, no matter how thick or thin the “disclosure” document is.

There is no significant advantage in the private market over the public market. Indeed, the reverse may be true. (Yes, I meant all of the ambiguity there.) Look to the underlying, and invest accordingly. Look at fees, and try to minimize them. Prize transparency, because it reduces risk in the long run. Those who are honest are transparent.

Posted in General

Originally Posted in The Aleph Blog

Sound investments
don't happen alone

Find your crew, build teams, compete in VS MODE, and identify investment trends in our evergrowing investment ecosystem. You aren't on an island anymore, and our community is here to help you make informed decisions in a complex world.

More Reads
How Soft and Hard Credit Pulls Affect Your Credit

It's practical to learn how to establish credit for your business. However, before you start applying for loans, weigh the costs as well as the impact on your business.

Money Scripts - How we Feel About Money

Ever thought about how you feel about money? Believe it or not, the way you think about money has a significant effect on your ability to grow and build wealth.

9 Quick Cash Advance Apps To Get You Money Now

A cash advance app is a type of financial application that allows users to request and receive money, typically within 24 hours. Many cash advance apps are available on the market, each with its unique features and benefits. Some popular cash advance apps include Brigit, Dave, Earnin, Chime, and Moneylion.

These Are The 5 Best Retirement Gifts For Women

When a person retires, giving them a gift to celebrate the occasion is a common practice. However, choosing an appropriate present isn’t always easy. If you aren’t sure where to begin, here are five of the best retirement gifts for women.

How long should you keep financial records after a death?

There is a copious amount of paperwork involved in organizing your finances. Tax season every year gives us an opportune time to go through the endless paperwork. We decide what to keep and what to toss- decluttering at its finest.

What Credit Score Is Needed For Care Credit?

When a person has high out-of-pocket medical expenses, figuring out what to do can be a challenge. Fortunately, there are potential solutions. In some cases, Care Credit may give you a simple way to handle the costs, settling your balance with your provider right away. Plus, Care Credit often runs promotional programs that may allow you to avoid interest while you pay off what you owe.

My Company Offers A Standard 401(K)-What Does That Mean?

When you’re starting with a new employer, you typically get access to a range of benefits. When it comes to retirement plans, many companies offer employees a standard 401k. If you haven’t had a 401k before, you may be wondering what a typical one involves. Here’s a look at the standard 401k, including what it is, how it works, and the benefits it can provide.

Fulfillment in Retirement

Fulfillment in retirement is my new goal. As part of my post-honeymoon period of retirement wanderings, I had a sort-of-crisis of success. After all, my career was successful! What more does one need in life? Once you have enough money, we know that more money does not make you happier or more fulfilled. What about success? Is enough success enough? Not if your goal is fulfillment in retirement.

Using RMDs to Assess Asset Allocation

Can you use RMDs to help determine your asset allocation in the retirement drawdown phase? Imagine you are living off your assets (taking an income from your nest egg). What might your asset allocation be to minimize the sequence of returns risk due to RMDs?

Am I investing for me or my kids?

Investing in retirement is all about tradeoffs. Of course, all decisions are tradeoffs—when you choose one path, you can’t go down the other—but let’s focus on retirement investing! What are the major tradeoffs you face when investing during retirement? Remember, this blog is for those who have oversaved for retirement. This is a safe space to discuss first-world problems! If you have oversaved for retirement, you need to decide on your asset allocation: how well do I sleep at night vs. how rich do I want the kids to be?

My Strategies For Dealing With a Down Stock Market

How do I handle my stock portfolio during a market downturn? How do I cope with seeing my stocks drop in value? Should I sell? Should I keep investing? These questions came up recently in the Simply Investing Forum. This blog post will answer these questions.

Market Musing 10-16-2022, Fed Fiasco 2022, Keep your hedges on

The SPX hit a 27.5% market correction last week. Why? Because Fed Chair Powell is forecasting another 100 to 125 basis points higher rate before the end of 2022.

Market Musing 10-10-2022, shots-fired-are-new-lows-on-deck

So good jobs data caused another market selloff. Why? Because Fed Chair Powell is forecasting another 100 to 125 basis points higher rate before the end of 2022.

Market Musing 10-04-2022, Is the Fed backed into a corner?

The Markets are bouncing off the hope that the Fed will slow down rate hikes. Fed Chair Powell is forecasting another 100 to 125 basis points higher rate before the end of 2022.

Still Within a Down Trend

stock market commentary

Cash Management for your Personal Finances

We often think about cash flow by looking in the rear-view mirror. What came in and went out last month or last year. Remember, the importance of building awareness

Goal Setting is About Process and Habits

Start reaching your financial goals by setting habits and processes

How Are NFTs Worth Money?

NFTs have been touted to just be pictures and nothing more. Find out in the article how NFTs are worth money.

Top Stocks for Beginners to try Right Now

Beginner stocks are investments a consumer will recognize that has a straightforward business model and proven stability

The Top Lifestyle Stocks to Buy Now

These are top lifestyle stocks to check out. These ideas come straight from the community

Resources for Publishers
Resources for New Investors