What is the Difference Between Energy and Utility Stocks?

PUBLISHED Nov 27, 2022, 7:51:08 PM        SHARE

imgStaff Writer

The Utility and Energy Sector Provide Electricity

So you’re a new investor jumping into the stock market. Because your monthly electric bill has been hurting your budget, you think it’s a good time to invest in your local electric company because they are definitely making a profit off you.

So as a new investor, you look up energy stocks. But all you can see are oil and gas stocks in the energy sector? When you finally look up your electric company, you find that its not in the energy sector, but the utility sector.
For the uninitiated, this seems odd. My electric company is providing me electric energy, doesn’t that make it an energy stock? Well you see, the entire process of delivering energy to your home and all the buildings in your community, can be broken down into two steps in a process. And the businesses that cater to those two steps in the process, as we will see, are vastly different investments with vastly different risks and opportunities.

The First Step - Oil, Gas and Coal

The first step in delivering energy to your home is to dig and drill for materials out of the Earth that we can efficiently burn to create steam, yes steam, that turns a turbine and creates electricity. This is the traditional energy sector. And what materials do we need to dig and drill for? Oil, gas, and coal.

Mining Coal

Image by Анатолий Стафичук from Pixabay

Even today with all our talk about renewable energy, the majority of all electric power made is through this archaic process. Burn it and turn it.

The Second Step - Producing and Delivering Electricity

Power Plant

Image by cwizner from Pixabay

Utilities provide the second half of the process. Utilities run the plants that burn fossil fuels. They run the transmission and distribution lines that provide that electricity to your home from that plant. And they ultimately bill you for the amount of electricity they provide you.

So that is fundamentally the difference between the energy and utility sector. But that is not the reason why Wall Street broke up the energy process this way. The reason why Wall Street categorized oil and gas stocks separately from utility stocks is that the two investments have vastly different return opportunities and vastly different risks.

Utilities and Energy Stock are Vastly Different Investments

You see, the oil and gas industry provide oil to a world-wide market with multiple other companies and even entire countries competing to provide oil and gas to the highest bidder. And because oil and gas are in constant demand, if supplies get limited, the price of oil and gas can skyrocket, as you’ve probably seen at the pumps. And supplies can get limited, very limited. With whole nation-states nationalizing their own internal oil industry, the very supply of oil can make or break a nation. Hence then the supply of oil is as erratic as politics because a lot of time it is controlled by politics.

Revolution can roil markets

One revolution can roil markets. Image by PublicDomainPictures from Pixabay

So, from an investor’s perspective, since the price of oil can change so rapidly, there are opportunities to enjoy the windfall of such high prices. Conversely, you could risk significant losses if the price of oil plummets. And though I must emphasize that there is nothing morally wrong with an investment with oil, it does feel at times that you’re making a deal with the devil because when the world is going through hardships and uncertainty, energy stocks will likely rise.

Due to the speculative nature of the energy sector, the industry is influenced heavily by the futures market. The futures market is where people buy and sell contracts to take in commodities in the future. And oh boy, not to go down a rabbit’s hole, but the futures market is where fortunes are made and lost every day. Volatility comes standard in the futures market.

The Utility Sector is Less Volatile

But while the energy sector, made up of oil, gas, and coal prospecting, is volatile and potential lucrative, the utility sector is the complete opposite. An investment in a utility has historically been stable, boring, and growing at a snail’s pace. While the energy sector could see a doubling or tripling of wins…. Or losses, a 15% increase in a utility in one year can be an exciting occasion for the utility investor… maybe even too exciting.

Utilities are really boring for many reasons, but the ultimate reason is that they pass all the volatility of the oil, gas, and coal industry onto businesses and consumers. For consumers, you simply get a higher utility bill when the price of energy goes up. The utility is going to make the same return regardless of the price of oil.
On top of this, utilities in the United States are also heavily regulated as many of them get to be a complete monopoly in their region. Utilities are regulated by “rate of return regulation” meaning that the utility can make only a fixed return.

Hence, when energy prices fall, the utility has to pass that savings to the consumer. By following these regulations, utilities are allowed to maintain their monopolies in a region [1].

Wind Turbines

Read More: The Safest Utilities to Buy Now

Utilities Rely on Debt

And finally, there is the real need for capital. Utilities are capital intensive. They own large plants and infrastructure and maintenance obligations. Debt is not just a tool use by the Utility, debt is an instrumental part of a utilities business. So instrumental in fact that many utilities have whole slides on their quarterly presentations dedicated to their credit rating. And how do they keep a high credit rating? They have run a consistent operation with steady, but growing, earnings coming in every quarter.

Because large bond investors aren’t just looking repayment every month. Large bond investors will intrude into the business by asking questions to ensure their very large debt doesn’t go into default. That means the utilities want their whole business, from dividends, to earnings, to growth, and costs, to all be stable.
This in turn translates into a vastly different investment from the energy sector.
To make things even more confusing, Exxon-Mobil, the largest stock in the energy sector, not only produces oil, but they use this natural resource to make plastics.

Hence, from a business standpoint, Exxon-Mobil could be categorized as an industrial stock as well.
As for utilities, with more investments in renewable energy, they are slowly cutting out the oil and gas portion of the electric production process as they are getting the energy from solar, wind and nuclear energy.

The Bottom Line

So the next time you come across the utility and energy sector, remember, the reason that they are in different categories is that they are completely different investment options for your portfolio. While the energy sector is volatile, speculative, and dominated by the futures market, the utility sector is stable, income focused, and dominated by bond investors.

Check out our companion video:



1). https://indianaenergy.org/energy-overview-public-utility/

Further Readings - Stock Ideas

Further Readings - A Guide to Investing in Utilities

Sound investments
don't happen alone

Find your crew, build teams, compete in VS MODE, and identify investment trends in our evergrowing investment ecosystem. You aren't on an island anymore, and our community is here to help you make informed decisions in a complex world.

More Reads
The Safest Utility Stocks to Invest in Q4 2022

We found the top 5 safest utility stocks based on volatility, drawdown, dividend policy, and dividend cuts. Why are utilities safe? We'll explain why.

7 High Return-of-Capital REITs

Real Estate Investment Trusts (i.e., “REITs”) are tax-advantaged income vehicles that have become increasingly popular with investors and institutions in recent years.

November 2022 Stock Considerations

With a new trading month already in full swing it is time, once again, to highlight some of my potential stock purchases.

Skyworks Solutions (SWKS) Stock: An Undervalued Chipmaker

Over the past five weeks, the market has been up 14.7%. Also, after the CPI report was issued last Thursday morning, the market and almost all the stocks had a tremendous run-up. In two days, the market is up nearly 7%.

2 Recession-Proof Utility Stocks With Safe Dividends

The Fed has raised the Fed Funds rate six times this year to combat inflation and the last four times at a 0.75% clip. The current 4% rate is the highest in well over a decade. But the Central Bank has indicated that it will take more pain to get that inflation genie back in the bottle.

WestRock (WRK) A Dividend Stock Comeback Story

Yes, this is a random WestRock (WRK) dividend stock, come back story. Why is it a comeback? WestRock decimated their dividend during the height of the pandemic from COVID-19. One of the world’s biggest, packaging companies reduced their dividend to $0.20 per share, per quarter from the high of $0.465.

AEP to Focus Capital Investments on Regulated Businesses, Reaffirms Operating Earnings Growth Rate of 6 to 7 Percent

Reaffirmed 2022 operating earnings guidance range of $4.97-$5.07 per share and midpoint of $5.02; 2023 operating earnings guidance range of $5.19 to $5.39 per share; Five-year, $40 billion capital plan emphasizes investment in wires and renewables

Southern Company - A Buy but Not Without Risks

We assess Southern Company to be a buying opportunity. For retail investors, this may be a good time to dollar-cost average into a position in SO.

Dividend Kings in Focus: V. F. Corporation

V.F. Corporation is a giant in the apparel industry. The company’s annual sales amount to nearly $12 billion, but the company has humble beginnings. It started all the way back in 1899 and has seen many twists and turns in the 123 years since.

October 2022 Passive Income Update – Lower Dividends, Higher Passive Income

The market decided to climb back up this month and then interest rates rose once again. The narrative hasn’t changed both Tiff and Powell have said they aren’t done raising interest rates in previous hikes. Unfortunately Tiff played his cards first hoping Powell would follow suit with a .5% raise and the US raised theirs .75% essentially devaluing our dollar. Inflation for Canadians should rise on this move alone as it now costs us more to buy stuff in usd.

Procter & Gamble Stock: Recession Resistant Dividend Aristocrat

When volatility grips the stock market, as it has this past year, income investors should focus on quality dividend growth stocks.

Dividend Income Summary: Lanny’s October 2022 Summary

This is what dividend investing is all about! Investing in dividend stocks allows YOU to earn dividend income, the best passive income stream! Bias, you better believe it.

10 Compelling ESG Stocks That Pay Dividends Now

In the world of investing, the goal is always to compound wealth as efficiently as possible. We think the best way to do that is to buy high-quality dividend stocks, reinvest the dividends, and stay the course over a number of years. However, investors can also infuse their own personal preferences or beliefs into their investing strategy, and still make great returns.

What are the Dividend Policies of the Top Utility Stocks

When an income investor researches utility stocks, the dividend policy is an important decision factor. Here are the dividend policies of the top utility stocks and what they say about the stock.

AMC Stock Forecast, Analysis, Price & News | Is AMC stock a buy

Based on the stock performance over the previous 8 years, AMC has traditionally increased by 80.5% during the following 52 weeks. Learn more!

Is Planet Fitness a Buy or Sell? PLNT target price

Based in Hampton, New Hampshire, Planet Fitness (NYSE:PLNT) is an American fitness facility franchisor and operator. Let's explore it!

Are we in an Index Fund Bubble?

Are we in an index fund bubble? Should you stay the course and keep investing, or should you sell and look for better opportunities? As with most things there is no one size fits all answer. The markets are in a state of turmoil, so it is easy to see why one would think that avoiding certain asset classes might be a good idea. Let’s take a look at index fund investing so you can see if it is right for you.

Dividend Stock Watch List: Lanny’s November 2022 Edition

Welcome back to another dividend stock watch list article! The stock market is still down almost 19% year-to-date, but the last full week of October there definitely was a big push!

Is Verizon a Good Dividend Stock?

Despite the recent uptick, the bear market is still growling in 2022. The Nasdaq and S&P 500 Index are down more than 20% each, while the Dow 30 is doing somewhat better. Consequently, many high-quality stocks’ stock prices have also declined, along with valuations. One such stock is Verizon Communications (VZ), trading near its 52-week low and the lowest price in a decade. But is the stock a value trap, or is Verizon a good dividend stock?

AWK Stock Forecast - Is American Water Works A Good Stock To Buy?

American Water Works (AWK) is a good stock to buy. Investors can take advantage of the lower price of this utility stock and get a stable dividend every quarter. AWK stock forecast is also positive.

Resources for Publishers
Resources for New Investors
Boosted with BossCoin
Financial Literacy Leaders
Tom Hamilton
Wise Intelligent
Mark Robertson
Kevin Matthews II
Akeiva Ellis
Brendan Dale
Kenneth Chavis IV
Sharita Humphrey