Dividend Safety Analysis: Franklin Resources (BEN)

PUBLISHED Feb 13, 2023, 8:11:30 AM        SHARE

imgDividend Power Blog

Dividend Safety Analysis: Franklin Resources (BEN). The firm is a Dividend Aristocrat and Dividend Champion with 42 years of increases, which makes it interesting to dividend growth investors. The dividend has been raised continuously since 1981. The stock also has a forward dividend yield of about 3.55%, making it interesting for investors seeking income.

However, the firm’s erratic revenue and earnings history since 2014 has caused investor to shy away from the stock. Despite fee compression and intense competition from index funds, the company has remained profitable. This fact, combined with Franklin Resources (BEN) solid dividend yield and excellent dividend safety metrics, makes this stock of interest.


Franklin Resources Overview

Franklin Resource is a global asset manager providing services to individuals, institutions, pension plans, trusts, and partnerships. Its funds are marketed under the Franklin, Templeton, Brandywine, Western Asset Management, Clarion, Martin Currie, and Royce brands.

At the end of Q4 fiscal year 2022, it had $1.4 trillion assets under management (AUM). Of this about 37% fixed income, 30% equity, 19% alternative, 10% multi-asset, and 5% cash. Approximately 72% of AUM is in US funds, with the rest in international funds.

Total revenue was $8,275 million in fiscal year 2022 and $8,018 million in the past twelve months.

Franklin Resources Revenue and Earnings Growth

Franklin Resources has struggled with revenue and earnings growth since the fiscal year 2014. In fact, according to Portfolio Insight*, companywide revenue, operating income, and net income declined from 2014 to 2019. It only reversed in 2020 because of market action and the Legg Mason acquisition.


Source: Portfolio Insight*

In addition, gross margins, operating margins, and net profit margins have trended down since 2015 since cost cuts and efficiency gains did not keep up with the decline in revenue and operating income. However, this downward trend of margins was recently reversed due to the addition of Legg Mason’s assets. That said, they are still volatile.

Passive Index Fund Are Popular

Active asset managers, such as Franklin Resources, are facing significant industrywide headwinds resulting from the rise of passive investing. Increasingly, retail and institutional investors are migrating to index funds or ETFs due to their very low costs and ubiquity. Fund costs are a penalty on investor returns. From this perspective, index funds have an advantage. They track the benchmark index, so costs and thus expense ratios are minimal. In addition, there is seemingly an index fund for almost any basket of stocks. So, investors can get exposure to large areas of the market with little expense.

Some active asset managers have bucked this trend, but Franklin Resources is not one. The company’s AUM has declined or, at best, remained flat year to year between 2014 and 2019. The AUM is impacted by market action, net flows, and foreign exchange. The problem for Franklin Resources is persistent net outflows despite market appreciation.

The firm has moved to an acquisition strategy to add to its AUM.

Fee Compression

Furthermore, the industry faces industrywide fee compression, particularly for equity funds. This fact has also contributed to lower revenue. Some industry watchers feel there is a race to zero, like stock commissions. Today, some index mutual funds have a zero expense ratio. However, zero fund fees are still not the most popular funds.

Fund Performance

Until recently, the problem has been compounded by relatively poor fund performance. However, most of Franklin Templeton’s funds are now outperforming its peers and benchmarks.

Fund performance has both a direct and indirect effect on revenue. First, a well performing fund will rise in net asset value (NAV), resulting in higher AUM. Next, good fund performance attracts retail and institutional investors. Ultimately, good fund performance will drive gains in AUM.

Growth by Acquisition

By acquisitions, Franklin Resources has decided to address its AUM, revenue, and margin challenges. In the asset management business, scale matters for operational efficiencies. For instance, it takes little in the way of additional cost for a fund to scale from $1 billion to $2 billion. The fixed costs are stable, and the variable costs increase only incrementally.Along these lines, Franklin Resources bought Legg Mason in 2020, significantly boosting its AUM. In addition, the firm acquired O’Shaughnessy Asset Management in 2021 with about $6.9 billion in AUM. In addition, it acquired Lexington Partners, an alternate investment firm, in 2022. This acquisition added another $35 billion to AUM. The BNY Alcentra acquisition adde to its alternative category.

Franklin Resources is buying smaller firms in a consolidating industry. Beside Legg Mason, Franklin Resources has acquired AdvisorEngine, Benefit Street Partners, Capstead Mortgage, O’Shaughnessy Asset Management, Lexington Partners, and BNY Alcentra in the past two years.

Franklin Resources (BEN) Dividend Safety

Franklin Resources (BEN) has excellent dividend safety metrics from the view of earnings, free cash flow (FCF), and the balance sheet. The forward dividend yield is now around 3.55%. This value is more than twice the average dividend yield of the S&P 500 Index.

From the perspective of earnings, the dividend is decently covered. Consensus FY 2023 earnings per share are $2.36, and the annual dividend is $1.20 per share, giving a payout ratio of ~38.1%. This percentage is a good value and well below our target value of 65%.

Payout Ratio

The trend is for the payout ratio to increase for Franklin Resources. According to Portfolio Insight*, the payout ratio was below ~20% for many years and only went over that value in 2017 and has trended up since then to more than 40%. However, the small recent dividend increases combined with the earnings boost from the Legg Mason and other acquisitions caused the non-GAAP payout ratio to decline. The most recent increase was to $0.30 from $0.29 per share.


Source: Portfolio Insight*

The dividend is well covered by FCF. In fiscal 2022, operating cash flow was $1,956.7 million, and capital expenditures were $90.3 million giving FCF of $1,866.4 million. The dividend required $583.1 million, resulting in a dividend-to-FCF ratio of roughly 31%. This value is conservative and below our threshold value of 70%.

Significantly, Franklin Resources’ use of cash flow has improved, and it is no longer buying back excessive amounts of shares. Instead, the current focus are acquisitions and shareholder return.


Debt is a bright spot since the company has a net cash position. At the end of Q1 FY 2023, Franklin Resources had $3,547.8 million in cash and cash equivalents on its balance sheet. There was zero short-term or current long-term debt, and long-term debt was around $3,370.5 million.

In addition, the firm had about $2,045.8 million in long-term investments. Interest coverage is more than 12.7X and the leverage ratio is 0.15X. Additionally, the credit rating agencies give the firm an A / A2 upper-medium investment-grade credit rating. As a result, there is little risk to Franklin Resources’ (BEN) dividend and safety from debt.

Franklin Resources’ Valuation

The market has punished Franklin Resource’s stock price, which is down substantially from the all-time high set in 2014 and is now trading at ~$33.698 (as of this writing). However, Franklin Resources remains profitable despite the challenges and still pays a solid dividend yield with excellent dividend safety metrics.

Franklins Resources is trading at a depressed valuation of ~14.3X forward earnings. This price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio is much lower than the S&P 500’s average of ~22.1X. Additionally, the current valuation is lower within the range in the past decade, but more than the span in the trailing 5-years. However, the reason for this point, is revenue and margin declines have persisted for several years. The stock is probably fairly valued, but the stock price has trended up from its recent lows during the pandemic.

Final Thoughts on Franklin Resources (BEN) Dividend Safety

Franklin Resources’ yield is attractive, and at approximately 3.55%, it far exceeds that of the broader market. It is also higher than many of the income stocks. But Franklin Resources is facing industrywide headwinds that are negatively affecting AUM and thus revenue and margins. The firm is following a growth by acquisitions strategy that has stabilized and even turned around revenue, AUM, and margin declines. For investors seeking income, the dividend safety of Franklin Resources is acceptable.

You can also read Dividend Safety Analysis: Apple (AAPL).

Related Articles on Dividend Power

Originally Posted in Dividend Power

BEN, Buy

Franklin Resourc...
Return: -24.62%

BEN, Buy

Return: -24.62%

Sound investments
don't happen alone

Find your crew, build teams, compete in VS MODE, and identify investment trends in our evergrowing investment ecosystem. You aren't on an island anymore, and our community is here to help you make informed decisions in a complex world.

More Reads
United Parcel Service (UPS) – Delivering Dividends in 2023

The year of 2023 has already started in turbulent mode. The S&P 500 is up almost 4%, as inflation appears to have cooled on earlier reports. However, I think the economy is being overlooked, as I predict we are still in for a rude awakening.

Why I’m Investing into Vanguard Dividend Appreciation (VIG) ETF Daily!

By the time of this article release, I have now had a daily investment into Vanguard’s Dividend Appreciation ETF (VIG), another wonderful Vanguard ETF. The community knows I buy Vanguard’s S&P 500 (VOO) daily and Vanguard’s High Dividend Yield (VYM) weekly, so what gives?

February 2023 Stock Considerations

With a new trading month already in full swing it is time, once again, to highlight some of my potential stock purchases. While the market had a nice bounce in recent months there is still no shortage of stocks that are becoming fairly valued to undervalued.

Recent Stock Purchase January 2023

It has been a very, very long time since I made two or more separate tranches of buys in a single month but sometimes the market has a flash sale and adding more shares is just too tempting to pass up.

Which Utility is Most Invested in Renewable Energy. Are They Worth Your Investment?

U.S. utilities are on a path to convert their power generation fleets to renewable energy. But are they worth your investment?

The Top Utility Stocks by Wind Energy, but Should you Invest?

The stock market may be selling renewable energy stocks at a premium. Let’s discuss which utility stock you should invest in that is also a good financial investment.

SCHD vs. VIG: Which Dividend Growth ETF Fits in Your Portfolio?

Dividend-yielding ETFs (exchange-traded funds) have become the rage recently as tech stocks on the Nasdaq have plummeted, and people are seeking more income. So it is no surprise that people have been talking about dividend growth ETFs like SCHD and VIG.

In a New Era of Bonds

Do I need Bonds in my portfolio? We are in a new Era of bonds, so I thought it was time to ask the question do I need bonds in my portfolio?

VOO vs. VYM vs. VIG – The Vanguard ETF Trifecta!

The GOAT of the industry. Vanguard. John Bogle. Bogleheads. The creator of the mutual fund and home of the best exchange traded funds out there.

The Zen Ten – My Top Picks for 2023

I’ve been publishing the Zen Ten list each December since 2008. I pick my favorites and stick with them all year – no trading.

December 2022 Passive Income

A new year has come. Man oh man did 2022 ever fly by? The market continues its downward spiral and we can see even better prices out there for long term investors. I think this will continue for at least the first half of 23, but who knows.

5 Key Benefits of Long Term Investing in Dividend Stocks

Long-term investing in dividend stocks provides the following 5 key benefits:

Dividend Income Update December 2022

The beginning of every month is exciting for all dividend income investors as we look back at the previous month and see how much passive dividend income our portfolios generated. No doubt, these are the best posts to write and read online as it only provides further proof that dividend investing can work over time and that anyone can create an ever growing passive income stream.

January 2023 Stock Considerations

With a new trading year already in full swing it is time, once again, to highlight some of my potential stock purchases. While the market had a nice bounce the last couple of months, there is still no shortage of stocks that are becoming fairly valued to undervalued.

3 Best Buy and Hold Dividend Stocks for 2023

Competition has heated more than ever in almost every sector. As a result, it has become challenging to identify the best buy-and-hold dividend stocks in 2023. However, some companies have a strong business model in place, and thus they enjoy a meaningful business moat. In addition, they have proved resilient to recessions.

High Dividend 50: Cogent Communications Holdings

Despite boasting 41 consecutive quarters of dividend increases and currently trading with a hefty yield of 6.4%, Cogent Communications is not making a splash with investors.

High Dividend 50: Enbridge Inc.

Enbridge Inc. (ENB) is a Canadian energy infrastructure company that offers a high dividend yield of more than 6% at current prices. While its valuation is not the lowest in the midstream space, the valuation is still reasonable and justified by Enbridge’s higher-than-average quality.

High Dividend 50: Leggett & Platt

Leggett & Platt may not be a well-known name, but it is likely that millions of consumers come in contact with the company’s products every day. Despite being under the radar, Leggett has increased its dividend for 51 years in a row, meaning it is a Dividend King.

Is Boot Barn (BOOT) a Buy?

Boot Barn Holdings (BOOT) is considered a BUY up to a price of $73.20. The company has performed well over the pandemic even though it’s in retail.

High Dividend 50: The Bank of Nova Scotia

The last time The Bank of Nova Scotia (BNS) cut its dividend was back in 1942, in the midst of World War 2.

Resources for Publishers
Resources for New Investors
Boosted with BossCoin
Financial Literacy Leaders
Tom Hamilton
Wise Intelligent
Mark Robertson
Kevin Matthews II
Akeiva Ellis
Brendan Dale
Kenneth Chavis IV
Sharita Humphrey